Cambridge vs Harvard, Oxford vs Stanford: An in Depth Look at University Admissions Processes and Climate.
Are you planning to get an admission into some of the best universities in the world? If your dream is to study in the historical universities of Great Britain and Northern Ireland or in the famous universities of America like Cambridge and Oxford or Harvard and Stanford respectively, then you should learn how they differ in terms of the admission procedures, academic environment, and students’ life. In this guide, we will enlarge on the differences between these two types of schools and draw attention to such important issues as university entrance, legacy system, meritocracy, and the peculiarities of the British and American college traditions.
1. University Admissions: Blind hiring: meritocracy vs. old boy network (Legacy)
Cambridge and Oxford have different admission strategies when it comes to university from what is practiced by Harvard and Stanford. These differences are a root cause of creating distinct communities in these institutions as well as the character of the students.
Cambridge and Oxford: Meritorious Presidents and Leaders.
In Cambridge and Oxford there is, of course, one principle that remains constant – the admission policy is based on merit. The following are examples of some of the distinguished institutions found in the United Kingdom, which enroll students with regard to individual merit, in an attempt to identify and enroll the best brains in the country, irrespective of their origin. Here’s what sets them apart:
- Focus on academic excellence: Teachers and professors evaluate students’ academic performance, abilities and interest in the subject they want to get a degree in.
- Leveling the playing field: The two universities have put measures that would put into consideration the fortune of the applicant so that any applicant from a less privileged background will not be locked out.
- No preferential treatment: It is important to note, unlike in the United States, Oxford and Cambridge do not give preferences to children of alumni or take into account their family’s endowments for their admissions process.
Harvard and Stanford: The Legacy Factor
On the other hand, Harvard and Stanford have recently been in the eye of the storm over their admission strategies as these are not purely merit based. Here are some key points to consider:
- Legacy admissions at Harvard: It is expected that every year about a third of Harvard students are legacy students – those whose parents were also students at Harvard. Some published records of the court show that legacy students are offered admission at a rate of more than five instances higher as compared to non-legacy students.
- Stanford’s approach: Of course, legacy preferences are not as strong at Stanford as they are at Harvard, but the school still takes them into account. A paper that was conducted in 2011 with thirty selective colleges revealed that legacy students benefited from an increase of about 23 % chances of being admitted once other factors were controlled.
- Donations and admissions: While the two educational institutions are Harvard and Stanford, both these universities have been accused of presenting strong correlation between large donations and increased odds of admission.
This difference in admission policies has led to some legal cases like the one in which Asian American students sued Harvard University for discrimination in admission.
2. Academic Culture: Comparison between British and American Universities
These differences can be observed in the general academic culture of UK and US universities and colleges.
Education and Career Goals
- Cambridge and Oxford: Students are considered to be more idealistic and likely to have obscure interests. Humble bragging is rampant and people tend to make light of their accomplishments.
- Harvard and Stanford: Students are generally more self-assertive and focused on their careers, with more importance placed on networking and job searching.
Classroom Dynamics
- UK universities: Class discussions do not receive as much attention as they should be given. For instance, in Cambridge, students can easily sit for hours and hours during lectures without speaking even when they are asked a question.
- US universities: Participation in class is strongly encouraged and is sometimes incorporated in grading policy, especially in Harvard Business School.
Academic Support and Facilities
- Cambridge and Oxford: Despite having some of the finest historical college campuses and building structures, these universities can be slower in terms of process and infrastructure than some of the best American institutions.
Harvard and Stanford: Respected for their modern architecture, comfort and convenience, as well as the range of services provided for students.
3. Student Life: A Comparison of Two Different Worlds
Thus, the student experience in the UK universities varies greatly from that of the US, which is indicative of the cultural differences between the two countries.
Social Scene
- Cambridge and Oxford: These universities are renowned for their collegiate systems, which provide a distinctive social setting. As it is well known, each college has its own traditions, formal dinners and wine cellars. The cities have high pub-to-person ratios, and there are occasions where alcohol is served during university-sanctioned activities.
- Harvard and Stanford: Though there are drinking cultures, these are not as popular and open as wine drinking cultures and are generally associated with beer drinking. Alcohol will be officially present in the Campus events to a lesser extent than before.
Extracurricular Activities
- UK universities: Pupils get involved in peculiar, formal clubs and organizations. Far less importance is placed on sports in the organized structure compared to institutions in the United States of America.
- US universities: Various clubs, organizations, and varsity sport teams are also very active in contributing to student life.
International Exposure
- Cambridge and Oxford: Students are generally more cosmopolitan and have a lot of international exposure.
Harvard and Stanford: They might be more likely to include a higher proportion of students with relatively restricted exposure to the international environment before entering university.
4. Cultural Differences and Their Influence on the Higher Education
Understanding these cultural nuances is crucial for prospective students, as they significantly shape the university experience:
Self-Promotion vs. Modesty
- UK approach: People prefer to underestimate themselves and to make them feel even worse, they better understate what they say. Consequently, there may be distaste of arrogance or anyone who is overly ambitious or has achieved a great deal.
- US approach: Compared to the previous generations, assertiveness and self-advertisement are more welcomed and even expected in academic and work environments.
Community Building
- Harvard and Stanford: These institutions realize that the development of community and school pride is one of the most important aspects that should be established right from the start of the institutions.
- Cambridge and Oxford: On the one hand, there is still a high level of community presence, however, there is less emphasis on building institutions’ appeal and creating people’s identity.
Academic Pressure
- UK system: Such concentration on ends of term examination creates pressure more of it rather than constant testing.
US system: Greater spread of tests, quizzes and other evaluations across the academic year but comes with its own stress such as high GPAs, and having to engage in many co-curricular activities.
5. Choosing the Right University: List of Consideration
When deciding between these prestigious institutions, consider the following:
- Academic interests: What university is considered the best for students planning to study in your field of specialization?
- Career goals: It is important to ponder how that each institution’s networks and reputation may fit in with your career goals.
- Cultural fit: Think about whether you would prefer a more subtle, scholarly atmosphere or whether you would prefer an atmosphere where ambition is not hidden and you focus on your career.
- International experience: Consider whether you prefer to study in your country or transfer to an international institution.
- Admissions chances: As much as this is so, one needs to be realistic as such factors as legacy status in universities in the United States exist.
Conclusion: Cherishing Quality in Higher Education
Regardless of whether you wish to study at Cambridge or Oxford, Harvard or Stanford, you are getting into a sphere of the highest learning and maximum prospects. All these institutions have their own traditions and innovations coupled with the fact that they provide the best intellectual environment.
Thus, the differences in university admissions, academic environment, and student experience between these UK and US universities are not an exception to this rule, but are rather the result of cultural differences. Cambridge and Oxford promote meritocracy and academics while Harvard and Stanford are more career-oriented with notions of legacy admissions.
However, only you can decide what is best for you to achieve your goals considering what you like and your background. So, knowing these distinctions you will be able to choose the institution that will contribute to your success both in academic and personal aspects.
Before you proceed to take the journey in higher education are you ready? Whether you prefer the historical colleges of Cambridge and Oxford, or the business oriented Harvard and Stanford, just bear in mind that what you make of your university experience is up to you. Invest as much time as possible for gathering information and try to visit the campuses, talk to the students and graduates to get the true picture of the institutions.
Are you ready to advance your education level? For more information on how to enroll to these prestigious institutions contact our educational consultancy services. You don’t have to let your dream of attending a prestigious university just remain a dream!
– The Author is Mr. Ajay Thiara, Founder and Managing Director of 360 College Review
Image Credit – Freepik